I've thought about this for a long time based on all the debates on this site and I 100% acknowlege that mentioning this topic is like touching the third rail on this board, so I completely expect to get roasted on this almost equally by both the public and private sides. (Yeah unity lol!)
Having said that, it is the season of giving and I am happy to share what I think could be a very interesting twist on how to handle the Public/Private debate here in Illinois so here I go.
What if as a concession to the continued excellence of the private schools specifically with regards to the CCL/ESCC that it is agreed to grant 20 automatic qualifiers to the Top 20 CCL/ESCC programs? Divide them into 5 divisions with classes ranging from 8A-4A. As automatic qualifiers these schools can schedule Weeks 3-9 games amongst themselves however they want in order to create good competition knowing they will ultimately qualify for the 8A-4A playoffs whether their final record is 2-7 or 9-0.
28 out of 32 teams outside of the CCL/ESCC still qualify for the playoffs in 8A-4A so maybe it knocks out a few 4-5 teams and low playoff point 5-4 teams but for the most part everyone making the playoffs now is still making it.
Here is the part that the public schools would be intrigued by. No matter the record, the Top 2 private schools in each 8A-4A division get a 1-4 seed in the playoffs and the Bottom 2 private schools in each 8A-4A division regardless of record get a 17-20 seed in the playoffs. Why would the public schools like this? Watch as the brackets play out and you will see that it balances the classes a lot better which is what the public schools are asking for in all of these different playoff modification proposals. When you see the matchups there now become plausible scenarios where public schools could sweep 8A-4A and yet private schools could also sweep 8A-4A. Hence your competitive balance. The main advantage though is those brackets will be more competitive which is what everyone wants.
We are going to exempt non Chicagoloand area private schools from this so Rockford Boylan and Springfield Sacred-Heart Griffin qualify like anyone else for the playoffs with none of these unique rules. Just no way to include them with travel considerations and honestly they aren't the ones really getting the hate about winning championships from public schools outside of some 4A-5A groaning about SHG once in awhile.
What I propose is that the Top 4 teams in the entire CCL/ESCC would be in a separate 8A Division.
Call it the Blue. In this case I'm putting Loyola, Mt. Carmel, St. Ignatius and Marist in there. Mt. Carmel is the only one that gets bumped up a class from where they are now. Again CCL/ESCC guys could do it differently however they want. Doesn't matter they are all in the playoffs regardless.
7A would be the Green. Brother Rice and St. Rita who already are in 7A would reside there. While it would be the decision of the CCL/ESCC ultimately to set these divisions just for this exercise I'm bumping up Joliet Catholic and Nazareth based off of past success. (This is the part where I expect to get all of the JCA and Naz fans hate lol...good luck to both of your teams this weekend and lets hope for an awesome final. Tons of respect to you both.)
6A would be the White. Providence, Fenwick, Niles Notre Dame and Benet would be here since I'm going mostly off of enrollment.
5A would be the Orange. St. Francis, St. Laurence, Carmel, and St. Patrick would be here.
Finally 4A would be the Purple. IC, Montini, St. Viator, and Marmion would be this division.
Marian, De La Salle, DePaul Prep, Leo, and maybe Aurora Catholic if they join would be in the Red and treated like how they are now with playoff qualification but minus the multiplier and success factor since it is not necessary anymore under this model. They'd be 3A-1A most certainly.
3A-5A is usually the biggest complaint area from the public schools like when an Montini or IC drops down to these classes. Now 3A-1A is wide open to mostly public schools outside of the occasional private school outside of the CCL/ESCC like Chicago Hope or Decatur St. Teresa. But again those types of schools aren't the ones getting the pushback from the public schools for winning state titles.
Remember all 20 of the CCL/ESCC teams in the Blue, Green, White, Orange, and Purple now qualify for the IHSA playoffs regardless of record. They play each other and then when Week 10 comes it is playoff time.
As an example of how this would work here is the new 8A playoff bracket. This is what that would look like under this new model. I'll post 7A-4A separately since it gets more complicated and takes more time to calculate as you go down in classes.
Again I know this is not anything anyone would go for outside of maybe a few of us on this message board to create more competitive matchups, but looking at this 8A bracket the small adjustments made make this quite intriguing for me to see how it plays out the rest of the way from 7A-4A.
Here is my rationale and 8A bracket played out until the Finals based off of my predictions on what would happen. Enjoy or hate. Either way enjoy the long holiday weekend!
CCL/ESCC BLUE (8A) AUTOMATIC QUALIFIERS
LOYOLA (1-2 seed and a 1st round home game)
MT. CARMEL (3-4 seed and a 1st round home game)
ST. IGNATIUS (17-18 seed and a 1st round road game)
MARIST (19-20 and a 1st round road game)
8A Field: Add Mt. Carmel and Marist and drop Edwardsville and Glenbard West based on enrollment
8A:
1st Round: #1 Loyola vs. #32 Plainfield North, #2 LWE vs. #31 Taft, #3 Mt. Carmel vs. #30 Glenbrook South, #4 Barrington vs. #29 West Aurora, #5 York vs. #28 Homewood Flossmoor, #6 Maine South vs. #27 Lockport, #7 South Elgin vs. #26 Lane, #8 Huntley vs. #25 Niles West, #9 Joliet West vs. #24 Oswego, #10 Warren vs. #23 Aurora East, #11 Belleville East vs. #22 Lyons, #12 Stevenson vs. #21 Naperville North, #13 Naperville Central vs. #20 Marist, #14 Minooka vs. #19 St. Ignatius, #15 Neuqua Valley vs. #18 Downers Grove South, #16 Palatine vs. #17 Sandburg
2nd Round: #1 Loyola vs. #16 Palatine, #8 Huntley vs. #24 Oswego, #4 Barrington vs. #20 Marist, #5 York vs. #21 Naperville North, #2 Lincoln-Way East vs. #15 Neuqua Valley, #7 South Elgin vs. #10 Warren, #3 Mt. Carmel vs. #19 St. Ignatius, #6 Maine South vs. #22 Lyons
Quarterfinals: #1 Loyola vs. #8 Huntley, #4 Barrington vs. #5 York, #2 Lincoln Way East vs. #10 Warren, #3 Mt. Carmel vs. #6 Maine South
Semifinals: #1 Loyola vs. #5 York, #2 Lincoln Way East vs. #3 Mt. Carmel
Finals: #1 Loyola vs. #2 Lincoln Way East
That Lincoln-Way East-Mt. Carmel semifinal would be absolutely epic by the way. I took LWE here just because I'm trying to show how this model would almost certainly create 8A-4A public vs. private finals which I think would be so much fun to watch and ultimately create a put up or shut up scenario that would absolutely light this message board on fire even more so than it already is during Finals Week
I'll work on sharing 7A-4A as I go through the rest of the adjustments here later. Enjoy!