Eagle great post! It would be so hard for IC to keep up in the ESCC, too small of a school. Look at schools like MCC, JCA, and Viator all in recent years have either just qualified by getting 5 wins with a less challenging non con schedule or in JCAs case not make it at all. Those are 5a schools too that if they have a down year they have to scratch and fight for anything to make the playoffs, we can't honestly expect that from a school that is two classes smaller than that.
I would love to see the old SCC come back, it was a really great conference to be a apart of. I would challenge any conference to have as many state titles as this conference did from 2000 to 2012. IC had 2, Montini had 5, St. Francis had 1, Driscoll 7, AC 3, MCC 1 runner up, Marmion 1 runner up. I may have forgotten someone but this was the premier 5a conference year in and year out. The Driscoll closing and addition of some low level football schools destroyed that conference because they all teamed up and left, leaving only 5 schools with nothing.
I kind of thought the addition of Fenwick and De Lasalle could have been a good fit competition wise in a new conference, but it would be hard to get them to leave the CCL. And MCC bailed out of that at the last second too, was not a huge fan of that but whatever