I mean I can't disagree. My only real counterargument is to say that the 99 JC squad on paper was bigger, faster, stronger, and better at football than the 99 Morris squad was. And it came down to a late game TFL and missed FG as time expired for the team that was physically better to pull out a squeaker.
I hope this version's team understands that reality. If they both play their A games, yes I believe JC wins. But that 99 team did not play their A game against that Morris squad and it almost ended their season (and the revival of Joliet Catholic football that ensued because of that season).