I love Freshman Football, its a good preview of the talent you can expect to see over the next four years but you can't base the next three seasons off the freshman year. So many things are going to come into shape the next few years. Freshman year is about development and learning the teams offense/defense and playing at a faster level. That's why there is no playoffs and barely an OT if the games ends in a tie, because in hindsight it doesn't matter (outside of the hoodies).
Finishing 6-3 and above is a really successful season that any Varsity Coach will be happy to build on....even 5-4 depending on the schedule. Of course they don't want to lose to Rice or Rita but it happens, you don't win State as Freshman. Every MC Freshman team goal is to go 9-0, but it doesn't happen often. 2017 and 2021 are the last two MC Fresh Squads that went undefeated since 2011, every other year dropped a game or 2 or 3. Even this years senior class went 4-2 in the Spring Covid year, and that was with Dupree and Startz.
These players are still developing physically and mentally, I don't know about other teams but Freshman don't touch the weight room until after the season in winter workouts. When you get to varsity you take the best of the senior class and mix them with the best of the junior class, occasionally adding in the stud Sophomore and go from there.
And yes, you will have to to factor in transfers, both players coming in and leaving the school. Some just don't like the Catholic School environment after the season ends, some don't like the commute, some don't make the grades.
All I can say is there is going to be some great football the next few years in the CCL Blue as these players move up.