You bring up 3 schools that have a combined 4 state titles and say "See, public schools can do it too.."
I can do the same thing, bring up 3 private schools that have a combined 35-40 state titles...
Jeez you are unbelievable. You never explain yourself, cherry pick statements, then make up facts, then you contradict your own statements.
First YOU ask how many state titles those teams have?
I present you the facts. (Its not like I picked Marian,Leo, etc, I pick CoM, the most successful private school in the last decade in Montini, and MCC)
You: completely ignore them.
I present the argument its not really a public vs private more of a "haves vs have nots" that student choose programs based on the coach's reputation and past success.
YOU respond with well BMacs coaches suck..so um your wrong. Then make up some stats of BMac having 5 D1 players. (Also its not mutually exclusive that a good coach = coach's reputation)
I agree with you that private/non-boundary schools should be at least in 5A because 3A football sucks.
You: completely ignore
Then you argue its because of a lack of D1 players
other poster prove D1 players do not guarantee a title.
Then you argue this gem, "They have one football state title in close to 30 years... in those years, we have pounded them pretty good across the board in athletics.."
WHICH BASICALLY DISPROVES YOUR ENTIRE POINT. So for the last 30 years HHS has been so much more dominant but BMac has the advantage? But you still cry saying its still not fair.
You: Ignore how badly you contradicted yourself.
Then you say, "I can do the same thing, bring up 3 private schools that have a combined 35-40 state titles..."
WTF, that goes back to my original statement about the haves vs have nots. Yeah go ahead and cherry pick MC,PC, SHG and yeah you get 35 (the haves) then you have some other 70 private schools that dont win.
Before you respond with a 1 liner that proves nothin or that has no explanation, let me be clear.
1) 3A football sucks, its awful, BMac and other privates should be in at least 5A
2) At the 7A/8A levels it is not an uneven playing field at all, since schools like LVille,GW, and CG are all successful and they still have these big bad powerhouse Catholic schools in their backyard stealing all their players.
3) I AM SAYING PUBLIC SCHOOLS CAN DO IT TOO! Its proven with LVille,GW, and CG. Sorry this inst AYSO soccer and everyone gets a trophy, winning state should not be easy. Stop being so soft, does GW make excuses for Montini being less than 6 miles away?
