All.... Is this a here we go again try. (lol) Ratsy
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Be careful what you wish for.Semifinals shouldn’t be at a neutral site but the higher seed should be the home/host team for the semifinal game
All.... Is this a here we go again try. (lol) Ratsy
Is there anything stopping private school representation?100% public school representation on the football advisory committee.
Beat me to it. What is the criteria for being on this committee and did any private schools express interest in being on it? No need for people to try creating a narrative that isn't there.Is there anything stopping private school representation?
Yes on the higher seed hosting always in a semi-final game.Semifinals shouldn’t be at a neutral site but the higher seed should be the home/host team for the semifinal game
Why?Be careful what you wish for.
We all agree that teams aren’t seeded correctly currently. If they went to a nationally recognized algorithm, and not a committee, for seeding, I can live with the higher seed getting the semi final home game.Why?
Not in favor a neutral site but the higher seed getting the home game, why not?
While I agree the seeding system is not ideal, why should the higher seed not host? In any system they should host, JMO.We all agree that teams aren’t seeded correctly currently. If they went to a nationally recognized algorithm, and not a committee, for seeding, I can live with the higher seed getting the semi final home game.
By the time you get to the semis, I don't think you'll have too many "incorrectly seeded teams". I haven't recalled too many times when, for example, a CPS team is undefeated and makes it to the semis without being legit.We all agree that teams aren’t seeded correctly currently. If they went to a nationally recognized algorithm, and not a committee, for seeding, I can live with the higher seed getting the semi final home game.
You might get a loaded side when it’s not 1-32 but generally I would agree.By the time you get to the semis, I don't think you'll have too many "incorrectly seeded teams". I haven't recalled too many times when, for example, a CPS team is undefeated and makes it to the semis without being legit.
Looks like advisory committees have one representative per IHSA board division. How are advisory committee members appointed or elected? Who appoints them? How long do they serve?Beat me to it. What is the criteria for being on this committee and did any private schools express interest in being on it? No need for people to try creating a narrative that isn't there.
Being that you don't have the answers either, yes it is a narrative that you are trying to push.Looks like advisory committees have one representative per IHSA board division. How are advisory committee members appointed or elected? Who appoints them? How long do they serve?
The fact is that there are no private school people currently on the football advisory committee, but they are members of other advisory committees. Boys lacrosse, for example, has THREE private school reps representing three different board divisions.
What if the answer to your question about private schools expressing interest in being on the advisory committee is yes?
MY question is how many of them, if any, were asked to be on the football advisory committee?
By the way, I note that the coach from Antioch's term on the committee is over soon. As the IHSA board division for Antioch and Carmel Catholic is the same, I vote for Jason McKie from Carmel Catholic to be the one to take the Antioch coach's place on the committee.
How's that for a narrative?
Not everything needs to be a public vs. private issue.
Because the seeding process is woefully screwed up!Why?
Not in favor a neutral site but the higher seed getting the home game, why not?
Agree it’s not ideal but why should the higher seed not get the home game? When we get past the 1st/2nd rd is it really that messed up?Because the seeding process is woefully screwed up!