ADVERTISEMENT

GREAT Question! What Position Do You Pick?

All..... Defense. Middle linebacker. More bang for your buck on an average team. Ratsy
 
If it can’t be QB, and assuming you have at least average talent everywhere else…. I’d go RB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McEvergreen
RB.
You’d get the ball in the best athlete’s hands nearly every play. Even if you had a LB on the Butkus/LT/Holecek caliber, they could still direct the play away from him.

Thus, Bo Jackson.
 
I would take a running back. I remember Rockford Lutheran before James Robinson, during James Robinson, and after James Robinson. They went from being well below average, to being a state title contender, to then once again being well below average as a team. James Robinson did not play for a Power Five team, but that was a recruiting oversight. He played for Illinois State. But then he started as an undrafted rookie for the Jacksonville Jaguars and was one of the top running backs in the NFL that year. He has been slowed by injuries since then. His story demonstrates what an outstanding running back can do for a high school team.
 
I would take a running back. I remember Rockford Lutheran before James Robinson, during James Robinson, and after James Robinson. They went from being well below average, to being a state title contender, to then once again being well below average as a team. James Robinson did not play for a Power Five team, but that was a recruiting oversight. He played for Illinois State. But then he started as an undrafted rookie for the Jacksonville Jaguars and was one of the top running backs in the NFL that year. He has been slowed by injuries since then. His story demonstrates what an outstanding running back can do for a high school team.
Just to fill in some details, Rockford Lutheran was 2-7 in 2011, the year before Robinson's freshman season. In his junior and senior seasons they went 11-1 back to back. Two years later, in 2017, they were back down to 1-8.

During his senior season in 2015, Rockford Lutheran won its nine regular season games by an average of 53.5 points. No team came closer than 37 points.

During James Robinson's rookie season with the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2020, he finished 5th in the NFL in rushing yards.
 
I think offensively, the only possible answer is RB. They can touch the hall 40 or more times a game. A dominant OT, WR, or TE is useless without other pieces around them. Obviously a RB benefits from those other pieces, but that RB can win games with just a few big plays.

There probably isn’t a defensive position that moves the needle enough to answer this question either. MLB and DT are fine answers, but an average team can still find ways to scheme around one star defender.

You have to take the RB and, assuming the team they are going to is just average, that RB should be talented enough to help out at LB, DE, or DB as well.
 
RB, although I think a team is better off missing their RB due to injury than an OLmen.
 
I've seen dominant 3* DTs shut down offenses. They're too disruptive. I've never seen a 5* DT, but I imagine they do what the 3 and 4* do, but worse. I've seen a number of 4* running backs be contained by good defenses. I don't know that I've ever seen a 5* running back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: corey90
I've seen dominant 3* DTs shut down offenses. They're too disruptive. I've never seen a 5* DT, but I imagine they do what the 3 and 4* do, but worse. I've seen a number of 4* running backs be contained by good defenses. I don't know that I've ever seen a 5* running back.
I like your thinking Bones! If you have a dominant NT/DT he can be a game changer, especially if the team relies on the running game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: all4theillini
I think offensively, the only possible answer is RB. They can touch the hall 40 or more times a game. A dominant OT, WR, or TE is useless without other pieces around them. Obviously a RB benefits from those other pieces, but that RB can win games with just a few big plays.

There probably isn’t a defensive position that moves the needle enough to answer this question either. MLB and DT are fine answers, but an average team can still find ways to scheme around one star defender.

You have to take the RB and, assuming the team they are going to is just average, that RB should be talented enough to help out at LB, DE, or DB as well.
So many ways to get an run-and-receive threat RB the ball, particularly with the possibilities of early or late motions of different paths from multiple spots in the formation. Also, the companion plays that can come off mesh fakes with a dominant RB open up the offense to the rest of the players. Throw in a "wildcat" series or two and potentially another offensive player is freed up.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT