I think everyone is sleeping on joey Schley from PC.
Three year varsity starter at PC during its golden age. Split player of the year in football with Randle-el (think Schley times, Randle-trib). Won a state title for PC.
Baseball-wise he also three year starter for PC. Drafted out of hs in the 20th roundish. Went to SIU. Set at least 5 records there, some that still stand, then ultimately played pro for about 3 years after graduating.
He's my pick.